Hand-tossed dough, house-made sauce, and toppings that actually taste fresh. That's the Tony's way — no shortcuts, no compromises.
Hand-Tossed Daily
Fresh Ingredients
Fast Delivery
Family Owned
Every pie starts with the same promise: quality ingredients, made with care, and cooked until it's perfect.
Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, veggie — our house favorites made the way they should be.
Order now
Bold combinations that push the boundaries — from buffalo chicken to Mediterranean veggie.
Order now
Spaghetti, fettuccine, calzones, and subs — full Italian-American fare for every appetite.
Order now
Garlic knots, wings, salads, and breadsticks — the perfect add-ons or light meal on their own.
Order now
Soft drinks, bottled water, and Italian sodas — cold and ready to go with your order.
Order now
Tony's Pizza started with one idea: make pizza the way your nonna would — with real ingredients, real patience, and zero shortcuts.
We still hand-stretch every dough ball. We still sauce our pies from scratch. And we still treat every customer like they're walking into our family kitchen.
That's why New Berlin keeps coming back. Not because we're fancy. Because we're honest about what good food tastes like.
Dine in, take out, or delivery — we're ready when you are.
Address
2020 S Calhoun Rd
New Berlin, WI 53151
Phone
(262) 827-2992Hours
Call us directly for the fastest service — pickup and delivery available.
(262) 827-2992Your pie is waiting. Call us or stop by — we've got a slice with your name on it.
